With a plethora of instruments, it can be confusing whether to invest in individual stocks or mutual funds. When it comes to mutual funds, there are many types, including active and passive options. Active mutual funds are managed by professionals who aim to outperform the market through selective trading, whereas passive mutual funds track a specific index to mirror its performance with minimal trading, like ETFs and index funds.
For beginners, investing can seem like a difficult and intimidating chore. Given the many possibilities, understanding where to put your money for potential returns while controlling risk is essential.
This article will delve into passive funds like ETFs, index funds, and actively managed mutual funds, what they are all about, how they operate, and, most importantly, their fundamental differences.
Find the right mutual fund and grow your wealth with Dezerv!
Understanding the Basics
What are ETFs?
An Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is a marketable security that tracks an index, a commodity, bonds, or a basket of assets like an index fund. ETFs combine elements of stocks and mutual funds. While they are traded like stocks on exchanges, with prices changing throughout the day, they provide diversified portfolios overseen by professionals.
You can imagine an ETF as a box of fruits, with every piece representing a unique instrument, such as apples, bananas, and mangoes. These boxes are bought and sold just like stocks.
Advantages and disadvantages of ETFs:
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Diversification: By combining several instruments, ETFs help to lower risk. | Trading Costs: Regular trading sometimes results in more expenses. |
| Lower Fees: ETFs generally have lower fees overall than mutual funds do. | Market Fluctuations: Prices change throughout the day, and some investors may find it dangerous. |
| Liquidity: Like stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can be traded all day long. | Complexity: Beginners may need help to grasp some ETFs. |
| Transparency: ETFs disclose their holdings daily, allowing investors to see exactly what assets are in the fund. | Tracking Error: Differences may result in small disparities in potential returns gained because ETFs do not precisely replicate an index it tracks. |
What are Index Funds?
Index funds are a type of mutual fund that mimics the performance of a specific market index, such as Nifty 50 or Sensex; they invest in the same instruments as the index and replicate its performance in equal proportions but at lower costs.
Advantages and disadvantages of Index Funds:
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Passive Management: There is no active management in such funds; hence, their managers do not have to be involved in actively picking stocks. This removes any emotional bias in selecting stocks. | Limited Flexibility: Index funds cannot benefit from short-term market opportunities since they seek to replicate an index. |
| Low Costs: Expense ratios are lower than those in actively managed funds. | Market Risk: If the value of the market index declines, so will that of the index fund. |
| Diversification: Risk can be lowered by investing in an index fund that exposes one to many different instruments. | Lack of Personalisation: Index funds might not precisely match risk tolerance or personal investment objectives. |
| Market Performance: Predicting potential returns is more straightforward with an index fund since its performance closely follows that of the underlying index. | No Downside Protection: Unlike some active funds that try to protect against market downturns or change their holdings based on market circumstances, index funds do not. |
What are Actively Managed Mutual Funds?
Let’s understand the meaning of mutual funds. A mutual fund invests in a broad range of stocks, bonds, and other instruments by combining the funds of multiple investors. Actively managed mutual funds are a type of mutual fund in which fund managers actively buy and sell investment assets with the explicit intention of beating some benchmark or index like BSE Sensex, Nifty 50, etc.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Actively Managed Mutual Funds:
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Professional Expertise: Managed by skilled professionals seeking potential returns. | Higher Cost: Fees for research and management can reduce potential returns. |
| Dynamic Management: Portfolios adjusted for market conditions to seize opportunities. | No Guarantee of Outperformance: Active funds may underperform benchmarks. |
| Risk Management: Managers can reduce exposure to high-risk assets. | Managerial Risk: Performance depends on the manager’s skill, and changes in management or strategies may affect potential returns. |
| Seek Potential Return: Aiming to outperform market indices. | Market Conditions: Even with active management, economic factors can impact performance. |
Key Differences between ETF vs Index funds vs Actively Managed Mutual funds
Exchange-traded funds, index funds, and actively managed mutual funds all pool money from numerous investors to buy diversified portfolios of assets; however, there are differences. Comprehending these differences will assist you in selecting an appropriate investment.
Management Style – Passive vs. Active Management
- ETFs and Index Funds: Under passive management, their objective is to emulate the performance of a specific index instead of surpassing it. This results in less frequent trading and reduced management costs.
- Actively Managed Mutual Funds: They are actively managed, in which case fund managers decide on asset allocation in an effort to beat the market. This can lead to higher management fees and more regular trading.
Trading Methods
- ETFs: They are traded on stock exchanges all day, the same as individual stocks. This allows investors to purchase and sell ETFs at market price.
- Index Funds and Actively Managed Mutual Funds: Each fund’s net asset value (NAV) is determined at the end of each trading day based on the closing market prices of its securities. Thus, investors can only purchase or sell units at the closing price.
Liquidity
- ETFs: Since they can be traded all day, they generally provide more liquidity. This will be helpful for investors who need quick access to their money or the option to have flexibility.
- Index Funds and Actively Managed Mutual Funds: Compared to ETFs, they are less liquid because they can only be traded at the end of the day.
Expense Ratios
- ETFs: Typically, ETF administrative costs are much lower than those of actively managed funds at below 0.20% per annum compared to some active fund schemes, which cost more than 1% yearly. Hence, they are a reasonably cheap choice for investors.
- Index Funds: Like ETFs, index funds have low expense ratios due to their passive management strategy. The total expense ratio for index funds and ETFs includes investment and advisory fees, and it should not exceed 1% of the average daily net asset over a fiscal year.
- Actively Managed Mutual Funds: They usually have higher expense ratios (>1%) because active management involves administrative expenses, fund management expenses, etc.
Trading Fees
- ETFs: Depending on the broker, they may pay commissions or trading fees, whether bought or sold.
- Index Funds and Actively Managed Mutual Funds: While mutual funds may have sales loads—fees paid when purchasing or selling units—you do not pay any trading fees in this case.
For first-time investors in any mutual fund, a fund house is allowed to charge ₹150 as a transaction fee where such transaction value is more than ₹10,000. This fee is ₹100 in the case of an existing investor.
Track, manage, and invest your money better with Dezerv!
Which One is Right for You – How to Choose Between ETFs, Index Funds, and Actively Managed Mutual Funds?
- Investment Goals:
ETFs offer flexibility and all-day trading, ideal for both short-term and long-term investors. Index funds are perfect for long-term investors seeking a low-cost, hands-off approach to match potential market returns. Although they have higher fees, mutual funds, especially actively managed ones, offer professional management and the chance to beat the market.
- Risk Tolerance:
Your comfort with market volatility greatly influences your choice. ETFs and index funds offer broad market exposure and diversification, reducing risk. Actively managed mutual funds provide focused strategies for specific risk profiles. For a consistent, low-cost approach, choose index funds. Consider ETFs or actively managed mutual funds if you can handle more complexity and potential return volatility.
- Convenience and Simplicity:
If simplicity without regard to trading strategies or market timing is what you value in management, ease and simple investment options provide it. Index funds and no-load mutual funds offer simplicity. ETFs’ trading character calls for more attention, even if they are flexible. Professional management offered by actively managed mutual funds can be handy if you want to let professionals make investment decisions.
Planning to start your investment journey? Connect with Dezerv.
To Sum Up
Your investment goals, risk tolerance, and cost preferences determine whether you choose ETFs, index funds, or actively managed mutual funds.
ETFs offer tax efficiency and flexibility for both short-term and long-term investors. Index funds provide a low-cost, passive approach to potential market returns. Even though they are more costly, actively managed mutual funds have professional management and seek potential returns.
Use this information to match your investment plan to your financial objectives.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to invest in mutual funds or index funds?
Among other types of investments available, Index Funds might be the best choice for passive investors, given their potential returns that match those of the market coupled with minimal fees. Professionally managed mutual funds can outperform the market; however, their performance is erratic, and they charge higher fees. This choice will depend on personal risk level, goals, and whether an individual prefers active to passive management.
Do ETFs pay dividends?
Yes, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can pay dividends if the underlying investments, such as dividend-paying stocks or bonds, generate income. In most cases, shareholders receive dividends regularly. However, investors must choose whether they would like the dividends to be issued in cash or invested back into more units of the ETF, following the regulations guiding it.
Which investment form diversifies the investor’s risk?
All three investment forms—ETFs, index funds, and mutual funds—provide diversification by pooling assets from many investors who buy a wide range of instruments. However, index funds and ETFs often offer more extensive, reasonably priced diversification through passive management. At the same time, mutual funds that are actively managed may also achieve diversification, but usually at higher costs.
Are ETFs better than index funds?
No, ETFs are not necessarily “better” than index funds in India. Both have advantages and disadvantages; the best choice depends on the individual investor’s needs and preferences.